Costs & Budgets

3 quotes, 3 very different prices: what is really inside each contractor bid

Same job, three bids, very different totals. A Somerville builder on what is inside a quote, why they differ and how to compare them fairly.

Finished white kitchen with a granite-topped island, two wooden stools, stainless steel appliances and hardwood floors
A finished kitchen from Magno & Co job files.

You asked three contractors to price the same job and got three numbers that don't look related. One is far below the middle quote and one is well above it. I hear this question from homeowners all over Greater Boston, often right before they have to pick one.

The gap is rarely about greed or incompetence. It usually means the three quotes describe three different jobs. Below is what sits inside a bid, why honest contractors still land far apart, a sheet you can copy to compare them, and the signs of a quote that is too low or too vague.

Are my quotes really that far apart, or is this normal?

It's normal. Checkbook, a nonprofit that shops local service companies, published Boston-area bid numbers in an article last updated in December 2021. Its undercover shoppers got bids for a standard full bathroom remodel from $8,500 to $13,250. Bids for a two-story addition ran from $190,000 to $321,000, a spread of more than $130,000.

Two cautions. The article was last updated in December 2021 and doesn't say which year it did the shopping, so today's dollar amounts are likely higher. I use it for the pattern, not the prices. The pattern is the useful part: for the same plans, Boston-area bids can differ by a large percentage. Checkbook also reported no clear link between price and quality in what it collected, which means the high bid is not automatically the good one and the low bid is not automatically the bad one.

So the total at the bottom tells you very little. Read what's above it.

What should be inside a complete bid?

A quote that fits on half a page with one number is not a bid. It's a guess. Here is what I expect to see in a real one, and what a missing line usually means.

Line in the bidWhat a complete bid saysIf it's missing
Scope of workRoom by room, what gets demolished, built, moved or replaced, and what staysYou and the contractor may picture different jobs
AllowancesA dollar amount for each item you'll choose later: tile, fixtures, lighting, appliances, countertops, cabinets, hardwareThe number is low until you pick something real
PermitsWhich permits (building, electrical, plumbing, gas) and who pulls themYou may pay for them later, or the work may start without them
Demolition and disposalDumpster, haul-away, and what happens if old materials turn out to need special handlingA surprise line item in week one
Protection and cleanupFloor and dust protection, daily cleanup, final cleaningYour floors and your patience pay for the savings
ScheduleStart date, how long it takes, what could move itNo way to hold anyone to a date
Who does the workTheir own crew, subcontractors, or a mix, and who runs the site day to dayHard to judge quality or accountability
ExclusionsA written list of what is not includedEverything not written is arguable
Payment scheduleEach payment in dollars, tied to progressCash flow risk on you

Why do honest contractors still land so far apart?

Even when everyone is straight with you, these are the usual reasons for a big gap:

  • Different scope assumptions. One bidder assumes the old subfloor is fine. Another assumes it gets replaced. One includes new wiring to the kitchen circuits. One only moves outlets. If your description was loose, each one filled in the blanks differently.
  • Different allowances. A $1,500 tile allowance and a $5,000 tile allowance look the same on a one-line total and can add thousands to the same bathroom. Checkbook makes the same point about cabinets, appliances and countertops.
  • Different labor models. Some contractors employ a crew. Some hire subcontractors for every trade. Some work mostly alone. Each model carries different costs and different strengths.
  • Different overhead. Office staff, vehicles, tools, licenses and project management all have to be paid from the job. A one-person shop and a firm with a full office will not carry the same overhead.
  • Different calendars. A busy contractor with a waiting list may price high because they don't need the work. One with an empty month may price to fill it.
  • Different knowledge of old houses. A contractor who has opened a lot of 100-year-old walls in Somerville or Cambridge knows what is likely behind yours: knob-and-tube wiring, sagging joists, lead paint, cast-iron pipes. One may price that risk in. Another may price a perfect house and expect to bill you later.

How do I put three bids side by side?

This is the part most people skip. Make a sheet with one column per bid and do it in this order:

  1. Write one scope. Before you ask for more bids, write a short description of the job and hand the same one to everyone. If you can, include plans, a fixture list and the finishes you want.
  2. List every line from the table above for each bid.
  3. Level the allowances. Pick one realistic number for each allowance and use it for all three. If one bid has $1,200 for fixtures and another has $4,000, add the difference to the low one.
  4. Add what's missing. If a bid leaves out permits, disposal or protection, ask for a number and add it.
  5. Compare the exclusions. Anything one bid excludes and another includes belongs in a line of its own.
  6. Look at the leveled total, then at the schedule and the people.

Here is a sample of what the sheet looks like. The numbers are invented to show the method. They are not real quotes and not Magno & Co prices.

Line (example bathroom)Bid ABid BBid C
Quoted total$36,000$52,000$61,000
Tile allowance$1,000$3,500$4,000
Fixtures allowanceNot listed$3,000$3,500
PermitsNot includedIncludedIncluded
DisposalNot listedIncludedIncluded
Floor and dust protectionNot listedIncludedIncluded
Exclusions listedNonePaint, rotted subfloorPaint, rotted subfloor, lead testing
Own crew or subsSubsOwn crew and subsOwn crew
Start / durationNext week / unstatedFebruary / 4 weeksApril / 5 weeks

In this made-up case, Bid A looks $16,000 below B. After you level the tile and fixture allowances (about $5,500 here) and add a permit, disposal and protection, a good part of that gap closes. What is left is a real difference, and you can now ask a real question about it.

Builder's tip: Before you compare totals, ask every contractor the same questions and ask for the answers in writing. Whoever answers clearly is often the one who will run the job clearly too.

What should I ask each contractor?

Send everyone the same list:

  • What exactly is in the price, and what is not?
  • What allowance dollar amounts are you carrying for tile, fixtures, appliances, countertops and cabinets? What happens if I pick something that costs more, or less?
  • Who pulls the permits, and which ones does this job need?
  • What are you assuming is behind the walls and under the floor, and what happens to the price if it's different?
  • Will your own crew do the work? Who is on site each day, and who do I call?
  • When can you start, how long will it take, and what would delay it?
  • How do change orders work, and how are they priced?

If you'd like a full set of questions, a contract checklist and scripts for the awkward moments, I wrote How to Hire a Contractor Without Getting Burned. My hiring checklist and a guide to checking a contractor's license are free.

What are the red flags of a quote that is too low or too vague?

A low price is not a red flag by itself. A low price you can't explain is. Watch for these:

  • One lump sum. No lines, no allowances, no exclusions. You can't compare it or hold it to anything.
  • Allowances that are far below the others, or "TBD" where a dollar amount should be.
  • No mention of permits, or "we don't need one" for work that clearly does.
  • Nothing about lead-safe work on a house built before 1978, or nothing about disposal and protection.
  • A big upfront payment request. Massachusetts generally limits the deposit to one-third of the contract price, with an exception for special-order materials. More on that in my deposit guide.
  • Pressure to decide today, or a price that is only good "if you sign now."
  • A price that is dramatically lower than the others with no explanation. Ask them to walk you through it. A good contractor can. A contractor who gets defensive, or says "we'll figure it out as we go," is telling you something.
  • No license or registration number on the paperwork.

A vague bid isn't always bad intent. Some contractors just write short quotes. Ask for the detail and see what comes back.

Is the cheapest bid ever actually the cheapest?

Sometimes. But the lowest number at the start is not always the lowest number at the end. A thin bid leaves room for change orders: items that weren't in the original price and get added once the work is underway. Each one can be reasonable on its own, and together they can close a large gap fast.

I'm not saying the low bid is wrong. I'm saying read it the same way you read the others. If the work you want is on the page, in writing, with real allowances and a clear list of exclusions, the low price may be a good value. If you're relying on the contractor's good memory, it's a risk. For how change orders should work, see my change order guide. For typical ranges on the job itself, my posts on kitchen costs and bathroom costs are a good place to start.

What does Massachusetts require in the contract?

Once you pick a bid, it needs to become a contract. Under M.G.L. c.142A, section 2, a home improvement contract over $1,000 must be in writing and signed by both parties. In plain words, it has to include:

  • A detailed description of the work and the materials
  • The total price and a payment schedule listing each payment in dollars
  • A scheduled start date and a scheduled date for substantial completion
  • The contractor's registration number
  • A deposit that generally doesn't exceed one-third of the price, apart from special-order materials
  • A statement that you shouldn't sign with blank spaces
  • A fully signed copy in your hands before work starts

The contractor must also tell you which permits are needed and that the contractor must obtain them. No final payment can be demanded until the work is completed to your satisfaction. This is why a detailed bid matters: its scope and exclusions are what you carry into the contract. My full contract guide goes through every clause. If you want help reading the contract, ask a Massachusetts attorney. I'm a builder, not a lawyer.

Want a second pair of eyes on your three quotes?

I'm Mateus, a licensed builder in Davis Square. Since 2020 I've renovated and managed over $5 million in projects around Somerville and Greater Boston. If you're holding two or three bids and can't tell what's different, book a free walkthrough. We'll look at the job together, and I'll help you build a comparison sheet. If you want a neutral person to level the bids for you, project management is $65 per hour, and my owner's rep cost guide explains how that works.

Frequently asked questions

Why are my contractor quotes so different?

Usually because the bids describe different jobs. Contractors make different assumptions about scope, put different dollar amounts in allowances for tile, fixtures, appliances and cabinets, use different labor models, carry different overhead, and guess differently about what is behind old walls. Level the bids on one sheet before you compare totals.

How do I compare contractor quotes fairly?

Give every bidder the same written scope, then list each line side by side: allowances, permits, demolition and disposal, protection and cleanup, schedule, who does the work, exclusions and payment schedule. Set the allowances to one realistic number, add anything a bid leaves out, and compare the leveled totals.

Is the lowest contractor bid a red flag?

Not by itself. It is a red flag when you can't explain it: a lump-sum price with no detail, allowances far below the others, no mention of permits, a large upfront payment request or pressure to sign today. Ask the contractor to walk you through the low number and put the answers in writing.

What is an allowance in a contractor quote?

An allowance is a dollar amount in the contract for items you will choose later, such as tile, fixtures, lighting, appliances, countertops or cabinets. If you pick something that costs more than the allowance, you pay the difference. Checkbook's Boston-area article, last updated in December 2021, notes that allowances differ between bids and can hide cost gaps.

How much can contractor bids differ in the Boston area?

In a Checkbook study last updated in December 2021, Boston-area bids for a standard full bathroom remodel ran from $8,500 to $13,250, and bids for a two-story addition ran from $190,000 to $321,000, a spread of more than $130,000. Those are older prices and the article does not state the year of its shopping, so treat them as a sign of how wide the range can be, not as current prices.

What does Massachusetts require in a home improvement contract?

Under M.G.L. c.142A, section 2, a home improvement contract over $1,000 must be in writing and signed by both parties. It must describe the work and materials, state the total price and a dollar payment schedule, give start and substantial-completion dates, include the contractor's registration number, and generally limit the deposit to one-third of the price apart from special-order materials. Ask an attorney if you want the contract reviewed.

See my published prices and how I quote a job, and the towns I work in.

Read this next

  1. Hiring & PlanningMassachusetts home improvement contract requirements: what must be in writingMassachusetts home improvement contract requirements under c. 142A: required terms, notices and your 3-day right to cancel, from a Somerville builder.4 min read · Keep reading →
  2. Hiring & PlanningChange orders in construction: what they are and how to handle them in an old houseChange order construction basics for Somerville and Cambridge homeowners: why change orders happen in old houses, what to put in writing and the red flags.4 min read · Keep reading →
  3. Costs & BudgetsCabinet Tariffs, Jan 1, 2027: Should You Order Before the Deadline?A 50% cabinet tariff is scheduled for Jan 1, 2027. What a builder sees on supplier invoices, how price dates and allowances work, and when ordering early is smart.8 min read · Keep reading →
  4. Hiring & PlanningHiring a contractor in Massachusetts: 8 checks before you signRegistration, licenses, the written contract, the deposit and who pulls the permit — what Massachusetts law expects, in plain English.3 min read · Keep reading →
  5. Hiring & PlanningMassachusetts contractor deposit law: how much can a contractor ask for upfront?Massachusetts contractor deposit law in plain English: the one-third cap, the special-order exception and what a fair deposit looks like in Somerville.4 min read · Keep reading →
  6. Hiring & PlanningHow Much Does an Owner's Representative Cost? Fees Explained for Boston HomeownersHow much does an owner's representative cost? How owner's reps charge, what the fee buys, and when it pays off on a Somerville or Cambridge renovation.4 min read · Keep reading →

Have a question about your project?

Plans, a sketch or just an idea — talk to me. You'll get honest advice and a clear written budget and schedule.

Free: a 30-minute call or a walkthrough of your home.

Prefer to write? Send me your project details. I reply within one business day.

5.09 Google reviews

Worked with Magno & Co?

A 1-minute Google review helps Somerville neighbors find a builder they can trust, and it means a lot to a small local business.

Call Free consultation